...

Why Do Parts Machined From Bar Stock Fail Under Complex Stress?

You specify high-strength aluminum bar for your parts, expecting top performance. Yet, they unexpectedly crack under multi-axial loads, forcing costly redesigns and damaging your reputation for reliability.

A bar’s strength is linear. Machining it carves into its inherent weakness—the transverse grain. We forge strength into the part’s geometry, creating a continuous grain structure engineered to withstand multi-axial stresses where a bar is fundamentally compromised.

I once had a client in the heavy machinery industry who was making complex hydraulic manifolds from large 6061-T6 bar stock. The design had ports on multiple faces, and they were experiencing leaks and cracks near the intersecting bores during pressure testing. The material strength was theoretically sufficient, but they were machining deep into the bar, exposing the weak, perpendicular grain structure. This created built-in fracture points. We switched them to a near-net shape forging. The forging process forced the grain to flow smoothly around the port geometries instead of being cut through. The result was a monolithic part with no inherent weak planes. The failures stopped completely.

What is 7075 Aluminum Good For?

You need a material that offers steel-like strength without the weight. But how do you know which aluminum alloy can truly handle the highest stresses your components will face?

7075 aluminum1 is purpose-built for high-stress, mission-critical applications where strength-to-weight ratio is the most important factor. It excels in aerospace structures, defense components, and high-performance machinery where failure is not an option.

A high-performance forged 7075 aluminum suspension component for a race car.

Think of 7075 as the specialist of the aluminum world. Its incredible strength, derived from its zinc-based chemistry, makes it the go-to material for parts that must endure extreme forces while remaining lightweight. You will find it in aircraft wing spars, landing gear components, and fuselage frames. In the defense industry, it’s used for everything from missile components to rifle receivers. However, this strength comes with trade-offs. It is not as corrosion-resistant as other alloys and is difficult to weld. This is where the synergy with forging is so powerful. Forging 7075 creates a single, monolithic part, which eliminates the need for weak welded joints. It also orients the grain structure to bolster fatigue resistance, maximizing the alloy’s inherent strength and ensuring the final component is as robust as possible. It is the perfect choice when you need maximum performance and reliability.

Is 5052 or 6061 Aluminum Stronger?

You are choosing between 5052 and 6061 for your application. Making the wrong choice means you could be sacrificing critical strength or ending up with a part that corrodes prematurely.

In a heat-treated state, 6061-T6 aluminum is significantly stronger than any temper of 5052. However, 5052 is the superior choice for formability and corrosion resistance2, particularly in saltwater environments.

![A split image showing a structural 6061-T6 frame on one side and a bent 5052 marine-grade panel on the other.](

This question is about choosing the right tool for the job. 6061 is a heat-treatable alloy, meaning we can dramatically increase its strength through a heating and aging process to achieve the T6 temper. 5052, on the other hand, is a non-heat-treatable alloy that gets its strength from strain hardening (work hardening). Even in its hardest temper (H38), 5052 is not as strong as 6061-T6. So, if your primary need is load-bearing structural strength, 6061-T6 is the clear winner. However, 5052’s superpower is its combination of excellent formability and outstanding corrosion resistance, especially in marine environments where 6061 can struggle over time. 5052 is the ideal material for bent sheet metal parts, boat hulls, and tanks. For structural components where reliability and strength are paramount, a 6061 forging is superior. For applications demanding extreme corrosion resistance and forming, 5052 is the specialist.

6061-T6 vs. 5052-H32 at a Glance

Property 6061-T6 5052-H32 The Better Choice For…
Tensile Strength ~310 MPa (45 ksi) ~228 MPa (33 ksi) 6061-T6 (Strength)
Heat Treatable? Yes No 6061-T6 (Strength Boost)
Corrosion Resistance Good Excellent (Marine Grade) 5052-H32 (Corrosion)
Formability Fair Excellent 5052-H32 (Bending)

What Is the Best Aluminum for Bending?

You need to form a complex shape from an aluminum sheet or plate. But choosing an alloy that’s too strong will cause it to crack, wasting material and time.

The best aluminum alloys for bending are from the non-heat-treatable 3000 and 5000 series, with 5052 being a top choice. These alloys offer excellent ductility, allowing them to be formed into tight radii without cracking.

A piece of 5052 aluminum sheet being cleanly bent to a sharp 90-degree angle in a press brake.

When it comes to bending, strength becomes a secondary concern to ductility. Highly ductile alloys can undergo significant plastic deformation before they fracture. The 5000 series, alloyed with magnesium, and the 3000 series, alloyed with manganese, are champions in this regard. Alloy 5052 stands out as a favorite because it combines this excellent formability with good strength and marine-grade corrosion resistance. You can bend it into complex shapes with tight corners, and it holds up well in harsh environments. In contrast, high-strength heat-treatable alloys like 6061-T6 and especially 7075-T6 are much less ductile. Trying to bend them into a sharp radius will often result in cracking along the outer edge. If you need a part with both complex geometry and high strength, bending a sheet is not the answer. That is the ideal scenario for a forging, where we shape the strong alloy into its final form without risking fracture.

What Is the Ultimate Strength of 7075 Aluminum?

You’re looking at the impressive strength numbers for 7075 on a spec sheet. But does that number translate to the real-world performance of your machined part?

The ultimate tensile strength of 7075 aluminum in the popular T6 temper is approximately 572 MPa (83,000 psi). However, this strength is directional and is highest along the direction of grain flow.

A graph showing the anisotropic strength of rolled bar: high longitudinal strength but significantly lower transverse strength.

The 83 ksi ultimate tensile strength of 7075-T6 is an incredible figure that makes it competitive with some steels. This is the number that gets everyone’s attention. However, this strength is not uniform in every direction, especially in rolled bar or plate stock. The manufacturing process elongates the metal’s grains, creating a linear structure. The material is very strong when you pull on it in the same direction as the grain (longitudinal strength). But its strength when pulled perpendicular to the grain (transverse strength) can be 10-15% lower. More importantly, its ductility and fracture toughness in the transverse direction are significantly reduced. When you machine a complex part with forces acting in multiple directions, you are relying on this weaker transverse strength. A forged part, by contrast, has its grain flow directed to follow the part’s contours, ensuring high strength is present in all critical directions, not just one.

Conclusion

Stop gambling with the hidden weaknesses of bar stock. Choose SWA Forging to engineer strength and reliability into every dimension of your critical components through superior grain flow control.



  1. Learn why 7075 aluminum is favored in aerospace for its strength-to-weight ratio and reliability. 

  2. Understanding corrosion resistance can help you choose the right aluminum alloy for your needs. 

Leo Jia

Hey, I am the author of this article,I have been engaged in the Aluminum Alloy material industry for 12 years. We have helped customers in more than 50 countries (such as CNC machining factories, Oil & Gas Pipeline Project,Aluminum Alloy Material Distributor, etc.).If you have any questions, Call us for a free, no-obligation quote or discuss your solution.

Newsletter

Subscribe to our Newsletter & Event right now to be updated.

You can leave any questions here

We will contact you within 1 working day, please pay attention to the email with the suffix “jia@ksxinan.com”

Seraphinite AcceleratorOptimized by Seraphinite Accelerator
Turns on site high speed to be attractive for people and search engines.