Skip to content 
Choosing between aluminum and zinc alloys for your project can be confusing. They look metallic, but their properties differ greatly, and picking the wrong one means potential part failure or unnecessary costs.
The main differences are: aluminum alloys are significantly lighter, have higher melting points, and can offer higher strength-to-weight ratios. Zinc alloys are denser, have lower melting points (ideal for die casting intricate parts), and offer good dimensional stability and impact strength.
As a manufacturer of aluminum alloy1 forged rings and discs at SWA Forging since 2012, we've helped countless clients understand material differences to ensure they get the best performance for their specific needs. While we specialize in aluminum, knowing how it compares to other common engineering materials like zinc alloys is crucial for making informed decisions. Let's look closer at what sets them apart.
What is the difference between aluminum alloy and not alloyed?
You hear "aluminum alloy" and "aluminum," but what sets them apart? Using pure aluminum when an alloy is needed could lead to a weak or unsuitable part for your application.
Pure aluminum (not alloyed) is soft, ductile, and highly corrosion-resistant but has low strength. An aluminum alloy combines aluminum with other elements (like copper, magnesium, silicon, zinc) to significantly enhance properties such as strength, hardness, and machinability.
When we talk about "aluminum" in everyday language, we often mean an aluminum alloy. Pure aluminum, or unalloyed aluminum (like the 1xxx series), is a relatively soft, ductile, and lightweight metal with excellent corrosion resistance and high electrical and thermal conductivity. Think of aluminum foil or some electrical busbars.
However, for most structural or mechanical applications, pure aluminum is too weak. This is where "alloying" comes in. An aluminum alloy is a material where aluminum is the predominant metal, but it's intentionally mixed with other elements called alloying elements. Common alloying elements include copper, magnesium, silicon, manganese, and zinc. These additions, even in small percentages, can dramatically change the properties of the aluminum.
By alloying, we can:
- Increase strength and hardness: This is often the primary goal. For instance, the 7075 aluminum alloy we sometimes forge for high-stress applications gets its immense strength from zinc and magnesium.
- Improve machinability: Some alloys are easier to cut and shape.
- Enhance specific characteristics: Like improving weldability, increasing fatigue resistance, or modifying corrosion resistance for certain environments.
At SWA Forging, all the large-diameter rings and discs we produce are made from specific aluminum alloys, carefully chosen and processed to meet the demanding requirements of our clients, including traders and machining companies who expect top-tier, certified materials. We simply couldn't achieve the necessary performance with unalloyed aluminum.
| Feature | Pure Aluminum (e.g., 1100) | Typical Aluminum Alloy (e.g., 6061-T6) |
|---|---|---|
| Strength | Low | High |
| Hardness | Low | Moderate to High |
| Ductility | Very High | Moderate to Good |
| Machinability | Poor (gummy) | Good to Excellent |
| Corrosion Resistance | Excellent | Good to Excellent (varies by alloy) |
| Primary Use | Electrical, packaging, chemical | Structural, mechanical, transport |
What is stronger, aluminum or zinc alloy?
You need a strong material for your part, but is aluminum alloy or zinc alloy the tougher choice? Making the wrong decision here could compromise the structural integrity and safety of your design.
Generally, high-strength aluminum alloys (like 7075-T6) can achieve higher tensile and yield strengths than most common zinc casting alloys (like Zamak series). However, zinc alloys offer excellent impact strength and can be very strong in compressive applications.
This question doesn't have a single, simple answer because it depends on which specific aluminum alloy you're comparing to which specific zinc alloy.
Aluminum alloys cover a vast range of strengths. For example:
- 6061-T6, a common structural alloy we often forge at SWA Forging, has a typical tensile strength of around 310 MPa (45 ksi).
- 7075-T6, a high-strength aerospace alloy, can reach tensile strengths of about 570 MPa (83 ksi).
Zinc alloys, particularly the Zamak series (e.g., Zamak 3, Zamak 5) commonly used in die casting, are known for their good strength, excellent impact resistance, and high hardness for a cast material. Typical tensile strengths for Zamak alloys might range from 280 MPa to 350 MPa (40-50 ksi). So, they can be comparable to or even exceed the strength of mid-range aluminum alloys like 6061 in some cases.
However, when you look at the strength-to-weight ratio, aluminum alloys often come out ahead because aluminum is much lighter (density of ~2.7 g/cm³) than zinc (density of ~6.6 g/cm³). This means for a given weight, an aluminum component can often be designed to be stronger.
Zinc alloys excel in applications requiring high ductility, toughness, and the ability to be cast into very intricate shapes with thin walls. Their impact strength is often superior to many aluminum casting alloys.
For the large-diameter forged rings and discs we produce, where high tensile and yield strength combined with light weight are often key requirements for our industrial and machining clients, high-performance aluminum alloys are typically the preferred choice.
| Property | High-Strength Aluminum Alloy (e.g., 7075-T6) | Common Zinc Alloy (e.g., Zamak 3) |
|---|---|---|
| Density | ~2.7 g/cm³ | ~6.6 g/cm³ |
| Tensile Strength | High (e.g., ~570 MPa) | Moderate (e.g., ~280 MPa) |
| Yield Strength | High (e.g., ~500 MPa) | Moderate (e.g., ~220 MPa) |
| Impact Strength | Moderate | Excellent |
| Hardness | Moderate to High | Good |
Which one is better, alloy or aluminium?
You're wondering if using an "alloy" is always better than just "aluminium." This confusion can lead to selecting a material that's either over-specified or not robust enough for the job.
An "alloy" (specifically an aluminum alloy) is generally better than pure "aluminium" for most engineering and structural applications because alloying enhances crucial properties like strength, hardness, and machinability, which pure aluminum lacks.
This question often comes from a slight misunderstanding of terminology. "Aluminium" (or aluminum) is the base chemical element (Al). An "alloy" is a mixture of a metal with other elements. So, when we talk about "aluminum alloy," we mean aluminum that has been intentionally combined with other elements to improve its characteristics.
Pure aluminum (like the 1xxx series, often 99% pure or higher) is relatively soft, not very strong, and can be difficult to machine (it tends to be "gummy"). Its main advantages are excellent corrosion resistance2, high electrical and thermal conductivity, and good ductility. It's great for things like electrical wiring, food packaging foil, or some chemical equipment.
However, for the vast majority of applications where strength, durability, and specific mechanical performance are needed – think aircraft parts, automotive components, structural beams, or the forged rings and discs we specialize in at SWA Forging – aluminum alloys are far superior.
By adding elements like magnesium, silicon, copper, or zinc, we can create aluminum alloys that are:
- Much stronger and harder: Tailored for specific load-bearing capacities.
- Easier to machine: Leading to better surface finishes and more complex parts.
- Weldable: Using appropriate techniques.
- More resistant to wear or fatigue.
So, "alloy" isn't just different; it's an enhancement. When our clients, including traders and CNC machining plants in the Middle East, come to us for customized aluminum solutions, they are always seeking specific alloys that meet their stringent technical requirements for performance and reliability, backed by our quality certifications (ISO9001, ISO14001, ISO45001) and options for third-party reports from SGS, BV, or TUV.
Why does aluminium alloy not rust?
You've noticed aluminum items don't get that reddish-brown rust like steel. Why is that? Understanding this helps in choosing materials for corrosive environments, preventing premature degradation.
Aluminum alloys don't "rust" because rust specifically refers to iron oxide. Aluminum does oxidize, but it forms a very thin, hard, and protective layer of aluminum oxide (Al₂O₃) on its surface, which prevents further corrosion in many environments.
The term "rust" specifically refers to the corrosion product of iron and steel, which is iron oxide—that familiar reddish-brown, flaky substance. Since aluminum alloys don't contain iron as their primary component, they cannot "rust" in the traditional sense.
However, aluminum is a reactive metal, and it does oxidize very readily when exposed to air or moisture. The difference is in the nature of the oxide layer that forms. When aluminum oxidizes, it creates a very thin, dense, and tightly adhering layer of aluminum oxide (Al₂O₃) on its surface. This layer is passive, meaning it's chemically stable and acts as a barrier, sealing the underlying aluminum from further contact with oxygen and moisture. This self-protecting oxide layer is why many aluminum alloys exhibit excellent corrosion resistance. If this layer is scratched off, a new protective layer forms almost instantly as long as oxygen is present.
This is a key advantage we highlight to our clients at SWA Forging, especially those in regions like the Middle East where components might be exposed to various atmospheric conditions.
It's important to note, though, that not all aluminum alloys have the same level of corrosion resistance.
- Alloys with high copper content (like the 2xxx series) can be more susceptible to corrosion.
- Alloys in the 5xxx series (magnesium as primary alloy) and 6xxx series (magnesium and silicon) generally have very good corrosion resistance, even in marine environments for the 5xxx series.
The choice of alloy, and sometimes additional surface treatments like anodizing (which thickens this natural oxide layer), is critical for long-term durability depending on the application.
Conclusion
Aluminum alloys are lighter than zinc alloys and can be stronger, while zinc excels in die casting and impact strength. Alloying aluminum drastically improves its properties over its pure form, notably by forming a protective oxide layer that prevents rust.
